How to Choose a Fireplace to Create a Cozy Home

a wood burning fireplace

Choosing a fireplace for your home is like picking the heart of the house. Adding or replacing a fireplace will enhance your home’s appearance and atmosphere and add warmth with a bit of charm. It serves as a focal point in the room, bringing a cozy and inviting vibe.

There’s no comparison to snuggling up next to a warm fireplace on a chilly winter morning. Fireplaces create a warm and welcoming atmosphere in homes and could potentially increase the resale value of your home.

How to Choose a Fireplace

One of the initial choices you need to make is determining the most suitable type of fireplace for your residence and daily routines. Wood, gas, and electric fireplaces all have their advantages and disadvantages.

There are various factors to take into account, such as the installation procedure, aesthetics, upkeep, and fuel needs. Below is a summary of the various kinds to assist you in selecting the right indoor fireplaces for your home.

Wood-Burning Fireplace

Fireplace to Create a Cozy Home
Photo by Rachel Claire

The traditional fireplace that most people picture includes a stone chimney and a fire burning logs. Wood-burning fireplaces create an authentic appearance, sound, and aroma of a wood fire. Their beauty is possibly unmatched, but the natural look comes with a price.

If you have a chimney already, the cost of installation is significantly cheaper. In any case, the result is a worthwhile investment that will endure for many years. Additionally, wood is the most cost-effective type of fuel.

Wood-burning fireplaces need constant supervision for safety, yet they can be invaluable. In case of a power outage, your fireplace can be utilized for heating the house and providing light.

When selecting a wood-burning fireplace, make sure to pick one that is big enough to warm your space effectively but not too big for the room. There are different options available, allowing you to find the right fit for your home.

Gas Fireplace

a gas fireplace in the living room

If you like the idea of a fire without all the effort, gas fireplaces are practical substitutes for wood-burning ones. Instead of using wood as fuel, natural gas or propane is used to feed the flames.

Many gas fireplaces come with decorative ceramic logs or unvented logs that imitate actual wood. Fireballs, glass crystals, and pebbles are commonly used to add a contemporary touch to the fireplace.

There are two primary categories of gas fireplaces – vented and vent-free.

  • Direct vent fireplaces emit a minimal amount of smoke that needs proper ventilation. If you have a chimney, you can install a direct-vent gas insert in your home.
  • If not, choose a gas fireplace without a vent. They do not emit harmful gases. You need to connect one of the types to an external source or the gas supply in your home.

Gas-fueled fireplaces are effective and generate the highest amount of warmth. They’re also more efficient and better for the environment.

In contrast to wood fireplaces, it is simple to control the heat by adjusting the gas level. To put out the fire, you just need to shut off the gas. Because they operate using gas, they are able to generate light and warmth when there is no power.

Select the venting option that suits your home best when selecting a gas fireplace. You have the option to combine various designs and opening styles to complement your interior decor and integrate the fireplace seamlessly.

Electric Fireplace

Setting up an electric fireplace is the most straightforward option. While it appears to resemble a fireplace, there is no actual fire present.

You connect it to a socket, and it emits warmth into the space similar to an electric heater. Because it does not emit fumes or soot, ventilation or maintenance is unnecessary. Electric fireplaces can be turned on and off simply by pushing a button.

Many simulate authentic flames by using fake logs in front of the digital fire. It is possible to show flames without generating heat and appreciate the atmosphere of a flickering fire. Some also allow you to select the style and color of the fire.

They’re energy-efficient and perfect for apartments or homes where installing a gas or wood fireplace isn’t possible. Instead of utilizing the furnace to warm up the whole house, you can opt for an electric fireplace to heat specific rooms. They are also significantly safer for use around young children and pets.

You can place an electric fireplace in almost any room as long as you have access to electricity. Simply select the size and style that suits your home the most.

Consider the Purpose: Aesthetic or Functional?

a fireplace with stone surround

Once you’ve got the type of fireplace in mind, think about its primary purpose. Are you mainly going for aesthetics, a cozy focal point that adds charm to the room? Or are you looking for a fireplace to heat your home during those chilly winter months?

If you’re going for aesthetics, an electric fireplace or a decorative gas model might be all you need. These options are designed to look beautiful without worrying too much about heat output.

On the other hand, if you want a fireplace for functionality, such as heating your living space, a gas or wood-burning fireplace would be the better choice.

These models are designed to throw off more heat, and many gas fireplaces come with thermostats to help you control the temperature in the room.

What Style Fireplace Do You Want?

living room interior
Photo by Alex Qian

Wood, electric, and gas fireplaces are available in a variety of styles to complement your home’s design and functionality.

Below are a few of the top designs to explore:

Traditional

The classic brick liner complements the traditional look of natural logs burning, enhancing the aesthetic of any interior. Classic fireplaces complement farmhouse, Victorian, nautical, Mediterranean, rustic, and craftsman-style homes seamlessly.

Traditional fireplaces can be electric, gas, or wood-burning.

Modern

Your fireplace will have a modern feel with bright flames above glass rocks, stones, and other special materials. Modern, glamorous, industrial, minimalist, and mid-century-style homes are enhanced by modern fireplaces.

This appearance can be attained using either electric or gas-fueled fireplaces.

Open-Hearth

person wearing gray and white socks near brown fireplace
Photo by Taryn Elliott

Experience the charm of a genuine fire with an open-hearth wood-burning fireplace. There’s nothing between you and the crackling logs unless you close the protective mesh screen, creating a warm and cozy atmosphere.

Firebox

A gas fireplace with a firebox resembles a classic wood-burning fireplace. This uncomplicated design showcases the beautiful flames without a glass barrier, so no need to clean them.

Mesh draw screens offer the choice of added safety and a heightened sense of authenticity.

Multi-view

a suspended fireplace

By having a multi-view fireplace, you can enjoy watching the fire from two or more directions.

There are various distinctive setups for multi-sided fireplaces. For example, a peninsula-type fireplace is built into the wall with three glass sides, allowing you to see through the flames to the opposite side of the room. Normally, they are gas models used for safety and installation reasons.

Budget: Know What You’re Spending

Of course, budget plays a big role in choosing the right fireplace. Here’s a quick breakdown of costs:

  • Electric fireplaces: Typically the most affordable, ranging from $100 to $2,500 depending on size and features.
  • Gas fireplaces: These can range from $1,000 to $5,000 or more, especially if you need to install a gas line or choose a high-end model.
  • Wood-burning fireplaces: Often the most expensive, especially if you need to add a chimney or install new masonry, with prices ranging from $3,000 to $10,000+.

Keep in mind that installation costs are also something to consider, especially for gas and wood-burning models that require professional setup.

Maintenance: How Much Are You Willing to Do?

Let’s face it, some fireplaces require more TLC than others. A wood-burning fireplace needs regular cleaning, from sweeping the ashes to having the chimney inspected and cleaned annually to prevent creosote buildup.

Gas fireplaces, while much lower maintenance, will still require occasional checks to ensure the pilot light, valves, and gas lines are in good condition.

Electric fireplaces, on the other hand, are practically maintenance-free. All you need to do is occasionally dust the unit and replace the light bulbs that create the flame effect.

Location, Location, Location

a fireplace in a bedroom

Next up: where will your fireplace be located? This is an important factor because not every type of fireplace can go just anywhere.

  • Living Room: This is the most common location, making the fireplace the focal point of the room.
  • Bedroom: Who wouldn’t love the cozy ambiance of a fireplace in the bedroom? Electric or ventless gas models are ideal here since they don’t require chimneys.
  • Bathroom: Yes, bathroom fireplaces are a thing! A small electric fireplace can add a spa-like touch to your personal sanctuary.
  • Outdoor Patio: If you’re thinking outside the box, an outdoor fireplace or fire pit can extend your living space and create a welcoming outdoor hangout. Gas and wood-burning models work great here.

It’s also important to think about how much space you have. Wood-burning fireplaces require a chimney, so they’ll need to be installed on an exterior wall.

Gas and electric models are much more flexible and can be placed almost anywhere, including interior walls.

Choosing the right fireplace for your home comes down to personal preference, lifestyle, and budget.

Whether you’re looking for a low-maintenance electric fireplace to add ambiance to your living room or a traditional wood-burning hearth to heat your home and make a design statement, there’s an option for every home.

Disclosure: Some of the links above are affiliate links, meaning that at no additional cost to you, I will receive a very small commission if you click through and make a purchase. These links help to pay the editorial costs of writing a blog. For more information, please read my full affiliate disclosure here.

I also use Artificial Intelligence Image generators to create some of my images. These are to show you examples of my ideas and inspiration when I cannot produce the real images myself.


Decortip model

Oh hey! I'm Abigail!

I’m here to help you inject a little bit of life into your home! Whether you are looking for biophilic design ideas, color or plants, or some inspiration for your home decor, I hope you find what you’re looking for!

Get Free Home and Garden Inspiration

Subscribe to get my favourite content by email.